Mathematical improbability proves Jesus

Reflection

Arguments from probability have long featured in discussions about the reliability of biblical prophecy. Some point to the sheer number of specific details in the Old Testament said to foreshadow the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus, and calculate how unlikely it would be for one person to fulfil so many independently. Such arguments can be striking, but they also deserve careful and honest handling, since probability calculations depend heavily on the assumptions fed into them, and scholars disagree about how particular texts should be read. What matters more than any single statistic is the wider pattern Christians have long recognised: a thread of promise and fulfilment running through Scripture, from the prophets to the Gospels. Whether or not any specific mathematical claim holds up to scrutiny, the deeper claim is theological rather than numerical, namely that God has been consistently at work across history, and that Jesus stands as the fulfilment of a long story rather than an isolated event.

Questions to sit with

• How persuasive do you find numerical or statistical arguments when it comes to matters of faith?
• What draws you more, evidence and argument or personal experience and relationship?
• Have you ever looked closely at Old Testament prophecy, and what did you make of it?

Topics